Approximately 38 days ago, the case of my VERY first foreclosure client was decided. As of today, 30 days ago, that same case was officially considered “Published”. Now for those of you who have not had faced the impending doom of foreclosure, you may not realize why this is so important. Actually, up until maybe a couple of weeks ago, (after receiving incessant compliments and communication from people all over the country on how this case will help them), I did not realize how much of an impact this case has had and will continue to have.

What Is This?

Now just what is this post all about? This post revolves around the case Glaski v. Bank of America 218 Cal. App. 4th 1079 (2013). The decision rendered by the 5th District Court of Appeal for the state of California provides that where a borrower has a home loan which is securitized, a borrower can challenge the securitized trust’s claim to ownership by alleging that the attempts to transfer the Deed of Trust to the securitized trust occurred after the trust’s closing date.  In addition, the justices held that borrowers have standing to challenge void assignments of their loans even though they are not a party to, or a third party beneficiary of, the assignment agreement.

How Did I Get Involved?

It all began around January, 2009, just seven months after I passed the California bar exam. I was on the job hunt and responded to a Craigslist post to assist an attorney with court appearances and legal research. Since I did not have a full time job, and wasn’t exactly sure what I wanted to do with myself in the legal world, I responded. For months, the attorney and I tackled what is generally referred to as “door law” (anything that walked in the door). I quickly learned the ins and outs of Family law, Bankruptcy, and tackled a few real estate issues. In the Spring of 2009, the attorney and I received calls from people who were depressed, distraught, heartbroken, and angry, with their dealings with their lenders. Many had been seeking loan modifications for months – some for years- with no success. Since we knew of no one else in the Fresno area taking on these cases (because they were not money-making cases), we decided to take them on. Me, being the new and ignorant attorney that I was, did not consider the amount of work, and little monetary reward that would accompany this area of the law. I did it because I wanted a challenge.

Around July, 2009, the attorney I worked with decided to shut his office down, as he had work in other parts of the country.  By that time, I had had so much autonomy as an independent attorney, I wasn’t sure if working for a firm would fulfill me. By August, 2009, I made the bold decision to open my own office. I scrounged up the little money that I had and threw an office together.

Then came my first foreclosure client- Tom Glaski.

His home was sold at a Trustee’s Sale just weeks prior to visiting my office. This house had been more than just a house for him – it was a place where he and his wife planned to reside after retirement, it served as a horse rescue, and it was the place he and his wife called home. He had made several attempts to save the home through a loan modification, but never received a return response. The only way he learned that his home was sold at a Trustee’s Sale was when an agent from the real estate company which was listing the home for sale served him with eviction documents. Just prior to facing an eviction trial, I agreed to take his case. I filed a Complaint based on the bank’s wrongful denial of his loan modification and sought to stay the eviction trial so my client could remain in his home until the wrongful foreclosure case was resolved. That attempt was a bust. By late October, 2009, my client and his wife were evicted from their home. For close to two years, we fought for justice – we fought for the “American Dream”. Ultimately, in late 2011, the case was dismissed, after all causes of action were sustained without leave to amend.

An appeal was filed in November, 2011, which caused the 5th District Court of Appeal to re-examine this case. After a year and a half of fighting at the appellate court level, with the introduction of appellate counsel, the 5th District overruled the Demurrer as to the 3rd, 4th, 5th, 8th, and 9th causes of action.

Why Is This Important?

Borrowers all over the country have been challenging this issue for years, along with issues related to forged documents, false affidavits, and a failure to establish the papertrail which leads to the purchase of any of these foreclosed homes. This also allows the borrower to challenge a lender’s claim of ownership when it attempts to transfer a homeowner’s Deed of Trust to a securitized trust after the trust’s closing date.

Now, for the first time – borrowers in California have the legal right to challenge the assignments of their mortgages and possibly prevent a Trustee’s Sale, and have the right to question the ability of a lender to sell a borrower’s home. 

Although this case isn’t over just yet, it creates a great opportunity for homeowners and definitely makes my job more exciting.

  1. due date calculator|10:49, 31. October, 2013 Reply

    do you have a twitter that i can follow

  2. Blondde|15:28, 27. December, 2013 Reply

    Hi Ms. Benitez,
    I have learned some very important facts sense my consultation with you:) I’ve emailed you a couple times and have a question about using Land trust law and an affidavit of appeal. Sis you already have what it takes to bust these banksters out by using their own written law against them! I am hopping you will take my case so you AND I can get to work on this atrocity that has infected the families of the “GOOD OL US OF A” (really….) If not i shall seek out someone else even though I KNOW you have the potential to sky rocket in to history.
    Again thank you for your time & kindness,
    Darla Nunes
    Please contact me ASAP to let me know if I may make a “mortgage pmt” monthly to you while we fight this case together, Amen!!

  3. Forge Of Empires Hack|1:08, 23. February, 2014 Reply

    Terrific post however I was wondering if you could write a
    litte more on this topic? I’d be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit further.

  4. practice Law|3:54, 14. March, 2014 Reply

    Hello, i think that i saaw you visited my weblog thus i came to “return
    the favor”.I’m attempting to find things to improve myy
    website!I suppose itss ok to use a few off your ideas!!

  5. GracieGirl|4:11, 16. March, 2014 Reply

    Hey, what are you trying to do?! Give lawyers a good name?! LOL You are awesome! Your perseverance is unmatched. Thank you.

  6. Lorayne Neely|4:45, 16. March, 2014 Reply

    Good job. Many people can use case as precedent as well as wells fargo v eroboband the laws regarding ny trust. Useful in different situations…like motion to dismiss for lack of standing…bankruptcy cases regarding challenging proof of claim or unsecure debt…and quiet title actions. The assignment being void and lender unjustly enriched as a result. We need to open all the way the pandoras box of discovery to determine just how much money was scammed and using us to commit fraud. Mortgage servicers should also be held accountable as well.

  7. AMERICANS AGAINST FORECLOSURES ( AAF )|14:54, 16. March, 2014 Reply

    Please help our hundreds of homeowners in California and around the USA. 60 million Titles are in jeopardy since Chain of Title has been broken and must return to the original pre-foreclosure owners.

  8. giovanni fettuccini|18:53, 19. March, 2014 Reply

    backs are not above the law “””they are the law”””

  9. giovanni fettuccini|18:55, 19. March, 2014 Reply

    banks are not above the law “”””they are the law””””

  10. schetovodstvo|22:27, 8. June, 2014 Reply

    I like it when people come together and share thoughts.

    Great website, keep it up!

  11. how to save my house|1:40, 9. June, 2014 Reply

    Hey there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my zynga group?
    There’s a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content.
    Please let me know. Thank you

    • Catarina Benitez|18:08, 30. January, 2015 Reply

      No problem! Feel free to Like me on Facebook too! Law Offices of Catarina M. Benitez

  12. Margo|1:39, 4. December, 2014 Reply

    I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you make this website yourself or
    did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz reply as I’m looking to construct my own blog and would like to find
    out where u got this from. thanks a lot

  13. the houston house|22:31, 10. March, 2015 Reply

    Good day! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group?

    There’s a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content.
    Please let me know. Cheers

 Add comment